Our winners are ... Dining
Mayor Wharton was quick to make note of a recent study that rated cities on their variety of food. “Memphis ranked high,” he noted, “from seafood to barbecue to Chinese to traditional cuisine. To prove the point, the mayor visited Corky’s, winner of Best Barbecue BBQ Sandwich, where he insisted on the biggest napkin they could provide. “I was raised not only on barbecue but also goat and raccoon – with lots of vinegar.” As he dug into the traditional fare, he remained diplomatic: “I’ll never rank barbecue. So long as it’s within a reasonable margin, I declare it all to be good.”
Later it was time for something completely different at P.F. Chang’s, Best Chinese Restaurant, where Mayor Wharton said his favorite dishes are wonton soup (“light and so much flavor”) and the restaurant’s Shanghai shrimp with garlic sauce. “It’s got that diversity,” the mayor said, “a taste for everybody.”
Talk about diversity — Memphis loves Blues City Café’s ribs, Huey’s burgers, Bryant’s biscuits, catfish at Soul Fish Cafe, deli delights at Fino’s, Gibson’s doughnuts, steaks from Folk’s Folly, Sekisui’s sushi and Ciao Bella’s Italian fare.
No misery served up anywhere.
Best Bakery
Winner: Muddy’s Bake Shop
Muddy’s Bake Shop wins Memphis Most again for being just so irresistible. It’s a comfortable spot, centrally located, the staff and menu are good humored and, naturally, the goodies are dee-lish. It’s the icing on the cupcake.
5101 Sanderlin Ave., 683-8844; muddysbakeshop.com
Finalist: La Baguette French Bread and Pastry
3088 Poplar Ave., 458-0900
Finalist: Panera Bread Co.
Several locations; panerabread.com
Best Biscuits
Winner: Bryant’s Breakfast
Bryant’s Breakfast is an institution, so those legendary biscuits get some respect. Although The CA’s queen of the dining scene — food editor Jennifer Biggs — said it’s the sausage she likes most, sandwiched in one of those biscuits. You make the call.
3965 Summer Ave., 324-7494; bryantsbreakfast.com
Finalist: Blue Plate Cafe
113 S Court Ave., 523-2050; 5469 Poplar Ave., 761-9696
Finalist: Brother Juniper’s
3519 Walker Ave., 324-0144; brotherjunipers.com
Best Breakfast
Winner: Brother Juniper’s
Brother Juniper’s has long been a breakfast favorite and has the Memphis Most pedigree to prove it. It’s hard to beat the comfort of homemade bread plus an array of omelets, waffles and big potato skillets. It’s the righteous thing to do, brother.
3519 Walker Ave., 324-0144; brotherjunipers.com
Finalist: Bryant’s Breakfast
3965 Summer Ave., 324-7494; bryantsbreakfast.com
Finalist: Blue Plate Cafe
113 S. Court Ave., 523-2050; 5469 Poplar Ave., 761-9696
Best Memphis Doughnut
Winner: Gibson’s Donuts
Gibson’s Donuts wins Memphis Most again for those crumby delights that make your eyes glaze in sweet happiness. As Aristotle (or maybe Geoff Calkins) probably never said, “As you go through life, whatever be your goal, keep your eye upon the doughnut and not upon the hole.”
760 Mount Moriah Roa<script type="text/javascript" src="http://web.commercialappeal.com/static/Scripts/tiny_mce/themes/advanced/langs/en.js"><script type="text/javascript" src="http://web.commercialappeal.com/static/Scripts/tiny_mce/themes/advanced/langs/en.js">d, 682-8200; facebook.com/gibsonsdonuts
Finalist: Howard’s Donuts
Several locations
Finalist: Krispy Kreme Doughnuts
Several locations; krispykreme.com
Best Business Lunch
Winner: Buckley’s Fine Filet Grill
Buckley’s Fine Filet Grill snags the Memphis Most prize but not because it’s a stuffy place to conduct business. It’s a great place to get good service, and a lot of care is taken with the cuisine. Steady and solid while delivering more than you expect — that’s good business right there.
5355 Poplar Ave., 683-4538; 919 Yates Road, 682-0570; buckleysgrill.com
Finalist: Houston’s
5000 Poplar Ave., 683-0915
Finalist: McEwen’s on Monroe
122 Monroe Ave., 527-7085; mcewensonmonroe.com
Best Deli
Winner: Fino’s Italian Grocery
Fino’s Italian Grocery is a grocery, yeah, and you can buy the ingredients for your sandwich there, but, mamma mia, why? Just get the sandwich already! And don’t forget the soup. There’s a reason this is the best in town, and your tummy will thank you for it. Mangia!
1853 Madison Ave., 272-3466
Finalist: Bogie’s Delicatessen
Several locations
Finalist: Lenny’s Sub Shop
Several locations; lennys.com
Best Barbecue Ribs
Winner: Blues City Cafe
Blues City Café wins this round in the world’s most competitive market. But the fare has gotten the attention of Bobby Flay, Bill Clinton and Bon Appetit magazine, so you can hardly go wrong. Plus, the cafe slings some mighty fine tamales and catfish, too. Bon appetit, really!
138 Beale St., 526-3637; bluescitycafe.com
Finalist: Corky’s
Several locations; corkysbbq.com
Finalist: Rendezvous
52 S. Second St., 523-2746; hogsfly.com
Best Barbecue Sandwich
Winner: Corky’s
Corky’s spans the globe and fills the belly with its long-popular hickory-smoked goodness. Co-owners Barry Pelts and Andy Woodman get those pork shoulders smokin’ from 20 to 22 hours before you sink your chops into ’em. “High quality product and best service day after day,” is the real secret, says Woodman. Slather it on.
Several locations; corkysbbq.com
Finalist: Central BBQ
2249 Central Ave., 272-9377; 4375 Summer Ave., 767-4672; cbqmemphis.com
Finalist: Tops Bar-B-Q
Several locations; topsbarbq.com
Best Catfish
Winner: Soul Fish Cafe
Soul Fish Cafe is quite a catch. Portions are generous, the price is right and most importantly, it’s some good eatin’, from the cat bites appetizers to the make-you-happy desserts. And that filet in between.
862 S. Cooper St., 725-0722; 3160 Village Shops Drive, Germantown, 755-6988; soulfishcafe.com
Finalist: Olive Branch Catfish Co.
9659 Highway 178, Olive Branch, (662) 895-9494
Finalist: Wolf River Cafe, Rossville
460 Main St. (Highway 194) Rossville, Tenn., (901) 853-2586
Best Pizza
Winner: Memphis Pizza Cafe
Memphis Pizza Cafe comes back as a Memphis Most winner probably because it eschews the routine pie in favor of letting you chew some scrumptious combinations of pizza goodness. Plus it has amazing calzones and sandwiches, and a pleasing variety of brews. Ricotta baby!
Several locations; memphispizzacafe.com
Finalist: Mellow Mushroom
3075 Village Shops Drive, Germantown, 907-0243; mellowmushroom.com
Finalist: Fox Ridge Pizza
1769 N. Germantown Parkway, 758-6500
Best Burger
Winner: Huey’s
Huey’s can’t seem to help itself. A basket o’ fries and a juicy burger is a thing of perfection and has been for decades. The World Famous is all you really need, but the Senor Huey has been gaining ground. No matter either way. The important thing is you know where’s the beef.
Several locations; hueyburger.com
Finalist: Tops Bar-B-Q
Several locations; topsbarbq.com
Finalist: Belmont Grill
4970 Poplar Ave., 767-0305
Best Southern Fried Chicken
Winner: Gus's World Famous Fried Chicken
You might make your own stab at Gus’s Fried Chicken with buttermilk, flour, paprika, cayenne pepper, salt, fresh ground black pepper and peanut oil, but you might also get more muss and fuss than Gus and you’d miss the funky atmosphere. It’s a multiyear Memphis Most winner for a reason. Crunch on!
310 S. Front St., 527-4877; 2965 N. Germantown Road, 373-9111; 215 S. Center St., Collierville, 853-6005; 6745 U.S. 64, Oakland, 465-1821.
Finalist: Jack Pirtle Fried Chicken
Several locations; jackpirtleschicken.com
Finalist: Popeye’s
Several locations; popeyes.com
Best Sunday Brunch
Winner: Owen Brennan’s
Owen Brennan’s Sunday Brunch is from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. and don’t dawdle. There’s a reason it wins awards. Executive chef Scott DeLarme understands the nuances of good Creole and Cajun cooking and you will, too, when you dig in.
6150 Poplar Ave., 761-0990, brennansmemphis.com
Finalist: The Peabody
149 Union Ave., 529-4199; peabodymemphis.com
Finalist: Boscos Squared
2120 Madison Ave., 432-2222; boscosbeer.com
Best Steak
Winner: Folk’s Folly
Folk’s Folly is a longtime local tradition that knows the joy of having a Memphis Most award and knows how to cook some prime beef. How about a chili-rubbed New York Strip? A braised veal chop, perhaps? How about starting with salmon mousse? It’ll get your juices flowing.
551 S. Mendenhall Road, 762-8200; folksfolly.com
Finalist: Buckley’s
Several locations; buckleysgrill.com/
Finalist: Ruth’s Chris
6120 Poplar Ave., 761-0055; ruthschris.com
Best Seafood
Winner: Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill started 10 years ago in St. Petersburg, Fla., and has taken finny delights into about half the states in the union. Aiming for a blend of the familiar and the exotic, Bonefish hopes you’ll be hollering “tilapia rocks” before the meal is done. Go ahead, reel it in.
1250 N. Germantown Parkway, 753-2220; 4680 Merchant Park Circle, Collierville, 854-5822; bonefishgrill.com
Finalist: Tsunami
928 S. Cooper St., 274-2556; tsunamimemphis.com
Finalist: The Half Shell
688 S. Mendenhall Road, 682-3966; 7825 Winchester Road, 737-6755; halfshell-memphis.com
Best Chinese Restaurant
Winner: P.F. Chang’s
P.F. Chang’s has that well-done stir-fry of hipness, an out-of-the-ordinary menu, upscale decor and family friendliness that makes it a winner. Get a mixed group of P.F. Chang’s veterans and newbies and listen to how many times you hear, “You gotta try this!” Which means, then, you’ve gotta try it.
1181 Ridgeway Road, 818-3889; pfchangs.com
Finalist: A-Tan
3445 Poplar Ave., 452-4477; atanrestaurant.com
Finalist: Formosa
6685 Quince Road, 753-9898
Best Italian Restaurant
Winner: Ciao Bella Italian Grill
Ciao Bella Italian Grill can serve up whatever Italian you need (fried calamari, chicken parmigiana, veal piccata) but it’s also a Greek place (souvlakia, spanakopita, lamb shank), and it hardly seems fair to have to make you choose. Guess you’ll just have to go back.
565 Erin Drive, 205-2500; ciaobellamemphis.com
Finalist: Pete & Sam’s
3886 Park Ave., 458-0694; peteandsamsrestaurant.com
Finalist: Carrabba’s Italian Grill
5110 Poplar Ave., 685-9900; 4600 Merchants Park Circle, Collierville, 854-0200; carrabbas.com
Best Thai Restaurant
Winner: Bhan Thai
Bhan Thai is one of those terrific gems that’s comfortable and sophisticated. Executive chef Alex Kamsrijan deftly handles complex ingredients and makes meals that will wow you. Thai it up — you’ll like it.
1324 Peabody Ave., 272-1538; bhanthairestaurant.com
Finalist: Bangkok Alley
Several locations; bangkokalley.com
Finalist: Jasmine Thai and Vegetarian Restaurant
916 S. Cooper St., 725-0223
Best Sushi
Winner: Sekisui
Sekisui turns 21 this year, and it’s been a couple of decades of sushi awareness for Memphians thanks to Jimmy Ishii. The restaurateur has been a huge influence on many local restaurants, but his early devotion to bringing sushi here has paid off. We know how to roll.
Several locations; sekisuiusa.com
Finalist: Blue Fin
135 S. Main St., 528-1010; bluefinmemphis.com
Finalist: Osaka
Several locations; osaka-cuisine.com
Best Mexican Restaurant
Winner: El Porton
El Porton is a repeat winner of Memphis Most thanks to a savvy blend of freshly prepared dishes, welcoming patio areas, good prices and various locations. Plus, there’s the efficient to-go service and a deep menu. So what’s stopping you, amigo?
Several locations; elportonmexicanrestaurants.com
Finalist: Las Delicias
4002 Park Ave., 458-9264; 3727 S. Mendenhall Road, 542-0170
Finalist: Happy Mexican Restaurante and Cantina
385 S. Second St., 529-9991; happymexican.com





